Growth unlikely in the weak Russian economy

Mar 07 2018

The experts speaking at Tuesday’s event included:

Dr. Sergey Aleksashenko, a Senior Fellow, Global Economy and Development, Brookings Institution and Free Russia Foundation expert

Dr. Anders Åslund, a Senior Fellow, Eurasia Center, Atlantic Council

Ms. Elizaveta Osetinskaya, Fellow, Investigative Reporting Program, Graduate School of Journalism, University of California, Berkeley; Founder, The Bell

The discussion began with an overview of the state of the Russian economy by Aleksashenko, who outlined the short and long-term factors that are predicted to limit economic growth to the 1.5-2 percent range over the coming six-year political horizon. The Russian Central Bank has successfully curbed inflation, but in order to do this, it has had to raise interest rates to very high levels, making credit very expensive for businesses and thus leading to weaker growth.

Meanwhile, the Ministry of Finance is seeking to rein in its budget deficit – despite very low national debt – while not raising taxes, as promised by Putin. This is expected to lead to spending cuts, lower investment, frozen wages and pensions, and lower living standards.

In the banking sector, a crisis among banks has prompted the state to take over, with nine out of Russia’s 10 biggest banks currently in state ownership. This means banks “will sooner rely on political motivations rather than economic”, said Aleksashenko .

In addition to these macroeconomic factors, Aleksashenko said stagnation is the result of a poor investment climate depicted by the poor protection of property rights, a lack of rule of law and the clampdown on free media. Thus, businesses are not inclined to invest and this is something that neither the Ministry of Finance nor the central bank can solve.

“This is a political agenda that is in the hands of the president”, said Aleksashenko, adding that supporting rule of law would lead to Putin’s party losing its majority in the parliament. “I don’t foresee him making any progress in the next six years,” he said.

Aleksashenko also mentioned sanctions and demographics as long-term factors of weak growth. The former could lead to a growing technology gap between Russia and the West and the latter – with a shrinking labor force and an increasing number of pensioners – will add pressure on the pension system and the budget, further reducing investment.

The war over living standards

Commenting on Putin’s recent annual address to the Russian parliament, Aslund of the Atlantic Council noted that the words – reforms, sanctions, and Ukraine – were all missing from the speech. “What Putin told us is that he is not going to do reforms whatsoever for his next six-year term”, said Aslund.

Aslund outlined a number of factors harming the Russian economy: Putin’s control of the state, the FSB and the court system, cronyism and the use of state corporations for “personal benefit”.

He pointed to the $26 billion fortune amassed by Gennady Timchenko, Arkady and Boris Rotenberg and Yuri Kovalchuk. Aslund estimated that $40-50 billion leaves Russia annually and Russian individuals keep between $800 billion and $1.3 trillion abroad.

“As long as Russia doesn’t have property rights, about 4-5% of GDP leaves the country each year”, said Aslund. And there is little incentive for Putin and the elites to ensure property rights in Russia if they have property rights abroad, he said, adding that large sums of money are being kept in luxury properties in Miami, New York, and London.

Meanwhile, Aslund said, war has become a distraction for citizens suffering from the declining living standards in Russia. “Russia cannot afford serious wars”, said Aslund, adding that in the era of hybrid wars, there is less need for direct military expenditures. The panelists agreed that if Putin had to choose between military spending and higher living standards, he would choose the first.

On the bright side, Osetinskaya of UC Berkeley said that the technology sector has developed rapidly and despite some negative trends, there is a growing number of entrepreneurs who open small and medium-sized businesses. However, there is also a large brain drain, with many educated people leaving Russia due to a lack of opportunities. “The government and the state don’t address their needs”, said Osetinskaya.

Another trend is that small and medium-sized businesses have sought investment opportunities abroad, whereas the oligarchs’ fortunes are flowing back into Russia due to the sanctions, said Osetinskaya.

by Valeria Jegisman

Free Russia Foundation joins global resistance to authoritarianism

Sep 19 2018

The annual Oslo Freedom Forum, which has taken place since 2009, was held in New York for the second time on Monday, September 17.

More

Marina Litvinenko: we are trying to stop the Russian propaganda machine

Sep 13 2018

Free Russia Foundation and the Atlantic Council organized this week an event with Marina Litvinenko – the widow of slain former intelligence officer Alexander Litvinenko – and family friend Alexander Goldfarb, to discuss their defamation lawsuit against Russian TV channels in the U.S. The panel discussion, held on Tuesday, September 11, also considered Russia’s use of the disinformation to discredit accusations over the poisoning of Alexander Litvinenko and Sergei Skripal.

More

Conflict of Interest is not Disclosed as Kremlin’s Lobbyist Interviewed on NPR

Aug 10 2018

On July 12, 2018, NPR’s 1A Program covering NATO’s 2018 Summit in Brussels featured Frances G. Burwell identified as Distinguished Fellow at the Atlantic Council (at 2:49 of the podcast).

More

Russian foreign policy: disruption and reflection of domestic policies

Jun 18 2018

On Thursday, June 14, the Center for Strategic and International Studies, a Washington-based think-tank, organized a panel discussion with Russian opposition leaders to explore U.S.-Russia relations in Vladimir Putin’s fourth term as president.

More

Last Address: a civic initiative to commemorate victims of Soviet repressions 

Jun 10 2018

On Monday, June 4, the Kennan’s Institute, a Washington-based think-tank, organized a panel to introduce “The Last Address” project – a civic initiative to commemorate the victims of repressions in the Soviet Union which originated in Russia and is gradually spreading to other countries. The panelists talked about the origins, success, and challenges of the initiative.

More